People's rights vs citizen's rights
Are you one of the People of the United States, as contemplated by the U.S. Constitution Preamble? Or, are you one of the citizens of the United States, as defined in the U.S. Constitution 14th Amendment?
Your answer affects the rights you have.
If you are one of the People of the United States, then all ten amendments are available to you. You have natural rights If you are a citizen of the United States, then you have civil rights [properly called civil privileges]. see Senate Document 108-17, p. 1006, 1007, Footnote 37, for details summarized here.
|Amendments available to U.S. citizens||Amendments not available to U.S. Citizens|
|1) Religion (free exercise, establishment), Speech, Press, Assembly, Petition||2) Right to keep and bear arms|
|4) Search and seizure||3) Quartering troops in homes (no cases)|
|5) Double jeopardy, Self-incrimination, Just compensation||5) Grand Jury indictment|
|6) (protection has been diluted), Speedy trial, Public trial, Jury trial, Impartial Jury, Notice of charges, Confrontation, Compulsory Process, Counsel||7) Jury trial in civil cases|
|8) Cruel and unusual punishment||8) Bail (mostly), Excessive fines under equal protection|
Senate Documents 103-6 and 108-17, Constitution of the United States of America: Analysis and Interpretation document the legal effect of your answer. An edition of the document and subsequent revisions is given free to all elected and past senators, congressmen, and vice presidents, delegates, and resident commissioners upon timely request to the Government Printing Office.
The doctrine of selective incorporation is the dominant doctrine for incorporating portions of the Bill of Rights for application to citizens of the United States.
- Newest Member
- Currently Active Users (1 member and 0 guests)
- Recently Active Users
- Quinton, admin, Chris, bluesbaby5050, Phaminator, sun, 11Orion11, Crackdown, fluxed, dvogel, Terran resistance, starperson, Tarheel Cowboy, shirleylo, bridgettb bridgettb, garlandvi garlandvi, Tantarum, Ecbra de Oaoj, Aya shin Tara, HebrianDaniel, MarbleMaster, Zeolaura, bradleyha bradleyha